A Third of Each Party Now Endorses Political Violence. History Warns Us.
New polling analyzed by Carroll Doherty, former political research director at Pew, finds roughly a third of both Republicans and Democrats now agree that 'Americans may have to resort to violence in order to get the country back on track' — with Democratic agreement more than doubling from 12 percent in March 2024 to 28 percent by September 2025, per an NPR/PBS/Marist survey. Republican support moved from 28 to 31 percent over the same period. A Gallup survey found 30 percent of adults under 30 said violence was 'sometimes okay' to achieve political aims — roughly eight times the rate of those 60 and older. Said University of Chicago professor Robert Pape to the New York Times: 'Once we have tens of millions of Americans supporting political violence, this can create spirals.' Every previous erosion of anti-violence consensus in American history — Reconstruction's collapse, the 1919 Red Scare, the late 1960s — preceded, not followed, institutional breakdown. The direction of causation matters enormously.